Unbiased reviews of new vinyl releases, audiophile reissues, and more

Monday, September 21, 2009

The Beatles Remastered: Stereo Revolver -- Review and Vinyl Comparison

the beatles! Pictures, Images and Photos

In 1966, The Beatles released their seventh studio album, Revolver. Heralded as one of the first psychedelic albums, Revolver features the use of reverse guitar, tape loops, and other effects on songs such as Tommorow Never Knows and I'm Only Sleeping. Revolver may also be the height of George Harrison's influence, featuring three songs written and sung by him.

Unlike the stereo version of their previous album, Rubber Soul, which features hard-panned left-right placement of vocals and instruments--and a hole in the center, the stereo Revolver features a more natural stereo mix. Today, Myvinylreview reviews the remastered stereo compact disc, which is found in the Beatles Stereo Box Set and can also be bought as a single cd.



(The Beatles, 1966)

In preparation for this review, I listened to a tube cut vinyl (-1/-1) stereo pressing, a Blue Box era (2-box) solid state cut U.K. vinyl stereo pressing, and compared them to the 2009 remastered stereo cd. As with all of the comparison reviews in this Beatles series, I have primarily listened to complete album sides, occasionally doing song-by-song shoot-outs as needed to confirm my initial impressions.


The overall treatment given to the 2009 remastered stereo Revolver is similar to what was given to the Abbey Road remaster (reviewed here). It sounds a bit more modern than either of the vinyl copies, and once again, while there is no evidence of the use of noise reduction, there is a pumped-up quality to the bass that suggests the use of some compression/limiting and EQ adjustment.



The tube cut vinyl has the most natural presentation of the three, with a full midrange that is particularly rich in the lower end of the mids. Vocals are full-bodied, and everything flows together very nicely. On the other end of the spectrum, the 2009 remaster brings a bit more detail to the mix, with stronger bass and more extended highs and upper-midrage clarity. But at times, this greater detail comes at the expense of the cohesion of the song.

On the 2009 stereo remaster of Got to Get You into My Life, McCartney's bass sounds like he's playing it with a hammer--the bass and drums dominate the mix, detracting from the horns, which are the focal point of this Motown-inspired song. It isn't all bad, however, as during the guitar break of the same song, the accentuated upper-mids and highs bring greater excitement to the moment compared to the smoother, lower-midrage sweetness of the original. Similarly, the remaster accentuates McCartney's bass during Taxman, but loses some of the realism heard on the tube cut vinyl in doing so.



(From left, George Martin and The Beatles in studio)

The Blue Box era solid state cut vinyl stands somewhere in between, having neither the gooey, lower-midrange richness of the tube cut, nor the increased clarity and bass of the remaster. While I'm not suggesting that you immediately sell your Blue Box copy, this 2009 remaster compares very nicely and serves as a nice alternative to the at times anemic-sounding solid state Parlophone cut vinyl--and for those bothered by surface noise or inner groove distortion, the lack of these nuisances may be reason enough to buy this remastered cd.

Remastered vinyl versions of these albums are forthcoming. While details have not yet been disclosed, I believe there is the potential to better these compact discs, especially if they're mastered without any compression/limiting, in the style of the Beatles in Mono Box Set. In the meantime, even if you are primarily a vinyl listener and are waiting for the remastered vinyl, this new disc sounds markedly better than the 1987 cd, and whether you're in the car, or listening on your Ipod at the gym, your ears will thank you.





RELATED: Second Listen: Beatles in MONO (Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band) Remastered Cd Review and Comparison to U.K. Mono Vinyl

First Listen: The Beatles in MONO Box Set (The White Album) remastered cd review and comparison to U.K. vinyl

Beatles Abbey Road Remastered Cd Review and Comparison to U.K. Vinyl

Beatledrops -- Samples of Beatles Mono and Stereo Vinyl, Remastered cds

Vintage Vinyl Spotlight: The Beatles Blue Box (BC-13)

42 comments:

Pete Bilderback said...

Thanks for the interesting comparisons. Since I do not have a nice collection of Beatles albums on vinyl, it is great for me to read this kind of analysis, and it is clear that you have listened very closely.

One thing confuses me about your analysis however. How do you differentiate between a bass boost caused by compression or an EQ boost versus a decision to simply let through what was on the original master tape to begin with?

As I'm sure you are aware, it was not uncommon in the 60s (and later) for mastering engineers to cut the bass level during LP mastering out of the belief that many people's home systems simply could not handle everything that was on the master tape. So how do you know when you are hearing bass that has been boosted in the EQ for the CD remasters versus just hearing it without the level cut that had been done for the LP? This only seems like a justified assumption if we know for a fact that the LPs were mastered without any EQ.

Anyway, please don't take the above as a criticism, I'm just wondering if you think there is a way to differentiate (absent of course having access to the master tape itself).

Keep up the great work!

MarkPMus said...

Please forgive me in advance for being a little off-topic as I don't limit my comments to Revolver. However I hope people reading this find my comments informative. (Also I use the word "you" meaning "one", not a specific person!)

It sounds from this review that the difference between solid state vs tube equipment has been described, with regard to the Valve mastered and transistor mastered vinyl Revolvers. If you read the hifi press at all, you'll know that valve amps are often punchy and full-bodied, at the expense of a little bit of "wool" - i.e. less detail at the frequency extremes. Transistor amps are often more detailed, but instruments and voices lack body, and are relatively sharp in the treble. Therefore, the differences in Revolvers may not be down to any treatment of the actual mixes. Rather, that is simply the difference between valve & tranny mastering equipment!

I have all the Beatles albums on vinyl (varying ages, from original copies to vinyl transfer of the 80's digital version), and I have to say that, when reproduced on fairly high quality equipment, (of at least the quality of a Rega P3, let's say) they really rock. The stereo mix of Hard Day's Night, despite the panning limitations, is uncanny. At times, I could almost see John harmonising at the mike, playing the guitar. Ditto Rubber Soul - Norwegian Wood in particular is so vivid it's possible to see fingers strumming the guitar strings.

So how do both CD versions stack up to this? Well, I have only heard the Past Masters 2009 remaster. As luck would have it, I also have Vol 2 on 87/8 release. Therefore I decided to make a composite track of Day Tripper, using Apple's Logic Software, to splice together segments of the vinyl (from 62-66), the 88 CD and 09 remaster. This was very interesting, in that the waveforms of all three are virtually identical. Listening also confirmed this. The biggest anomaly is the relatively huge amount of reverb that has been applied to the 87 version. I believe Martin went back to the mixer tapes and used 80's 16-bit digital reverb to reconstruct some of the effects, and this has not been entirely successful. In this song's case, some of the pace, rhythm and timing has suffered. EQ wise, it is also more trebly than either the vinyl or 09.

I think the 09 stacks up to the vinyl very well indeed. It is a bit cleaner - leading edges of notes are slightly more defined - but there are no obvious EQ or loudness war nasties. In faqct the volume levels between all three are about the same. None of the editions sounds bad BAD - and I believe it would take a very high quality hi fi set up to appreciate much of the difference between even the 2 CD editions.

So my advice is - if you have only heard the Beatles on 87 CD, and have no ambition to buy a quality record deck, then provided your CD system is up to revealing it, the 2009's will recreate some of the magic that the 87's lost. If you have good copies of the records, and a quality deck, then you probably don't need the remasters. Unless of course, you have gaps in your mono collection that need plugging.

Now, if only all albums were remastered/mastered in this way...

Anonymous said...

Dogdamnjamesboy says:

The remastered "Revolver" is an awful lot better than certain others in this series. But you need to reduce the stereo image at least some 50 percent. Domestic stereo Hi-Fi systems in the 1960s (a rare commodity outside the US, incidentally) did not have today's perscribed three metres between the speakers, but rather half of that, which is what these mixes were made for, obviously. A small mixer stuck in between your CD player and pre amp can solve that easily and I strongly recommend it. You're not gonna believe how much it helps until you've tried it. I sometimes even prefer it to the mono mixes, particularly the so-called "White Album"

Anonymous said...

Can someone please clarify the difference between the stereo version of Revolver included as a bonus on the 2009 mono CD remaster and the stand-alone 2009 stereo CD remaster ?

My Vinyl Review said...

There is only one remastered stereo cd version of Revolver--and it is available either as a single disc or as part of the Stereo box set. The only discs within the Mono box set that come with stereo bonus tracks are Help! and Rubber Soul. Hope that helps.

Anonymous said...

Greаt іtems from уou, man. I have be aware your stuff prevіоus to and уou're simply extremely great. I actually like what you've bought right heге,
certаinly liκе whаt you are saying
аnd the way іn which bу ωhich you assert іt.
You're making it entertaining and you continue to care for to stay it wise. I can not wait to read far more from you. That is actually a tremendous site.

Feel free to visit my website: article kevo

Anonymous said...

I'll immediately grab your rss feed as I can not find your email subscription link or newsletter service. Do you've
аny? Plеаse permit mе reсognise in order that I maу just subsсribe.

Thanks.

Ϻy wеbsіtе :: kontent machine coupon

Anonymous said...

Oh my goodness! Amazing artiсle dude! Thаnk you so much, Hοweѵer
Ӏ am eхрerіencing iѕѕues with уοur RSS.
I dοn't understand the reason why I can't subsсribe to it.
Іs theгe аnybody gеtting the sаme
RЅS pгoblеms? Anyone thаt κnows the
solution can you kindly respοnԁ?

Thanх!!

Mу blog :: gsa search engine ranker warrior forum

Anonymous said...

Curгently it sounds lіke Mοѵable
Type іs the top blοggіng platform available гіght noω.
(fгom what Ι've read) Is that what you're using on
your blog?

Feel free tο vіsit my ωebsite
... paleodietprimal.info

Anonymous said...

Ӏ will right aωay tаκe holԁ of yοur гsѕ feed as I can't find your email subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you'vе anу?
Kindly allow mе realize ѕo that I mаy ѕubscribe.
Thanks.

My ωebsitе :: wiki.postgresqlrussia.org

Anonymous said...

Greetings! Veгy uѕeful аdѵicе within
thіs articlе! It's the little changes that make the biggest changes. Many thanks for sharing!

Feel free to surf to my weblog easterhegg.ch

Anonymous said...

google law firm

Anonymous said...

The skit resulted in a standing ovation from the
audience. LG Cookie apps can basically be any application written in Java.
You'll have the added bonus of the online security and anonymity that VPNs provide as well.

Here is my blog: http://www.magnoliastatekennels.com

Anonymous said...

While you are reeling a fish in, your whole body is being used, so you can easily slip on a wet floor.
When it comes to the task of hiring a fishing charter, it is always best to try going to
a new location, something that you have never been to before.
To get hold of some keramine visit Willisworms (very few bait
companies sell it and it is on a special deal there.



Stop by my site http://fishing.seweb.de/fishing-basics-that-anyone-can-use/

Anonymous said...

DISH Network will roll out Video on Demand (VOD) service by March, 2006 to new customers with DISH
Network's digital video recorder (DVR), the DISH Player-DVR 625. Warriors must learn to balance their material desires with their spiritual desires. Schwimmer and English part-time photographer Zoe began dating then and married in a private ceremony last June after announcing their engagement in March 2010.

Stop by my web page; http://www.webdevmobile.com/xe/50563

Anonymous said...

You don't need to take my word for this, you can read the reviews for yourself. Don't
think you need an expensive camera and equipment setup either.
This often enables consumers to review each camera individually to get all the details and find out what is included with their
purchase.

Feel free to surf to my webpage - Wiifli.Com

Anonymous said...

This helps business managers to determine what the general public thinks about
their products or services. According to online music provider Pandora
the legislation will help end the discrimination against internet radio.
This powerful and versatile solution is also available
in three different versions, so you should have no trouble finding
the perfect one for you.

My web-site; internet radio advertising agency

Anonymous said...

But with Nexus Radio the only settings you have to worry about are where you want to save your
files and what file type you want to save it as. It was an entertaining radio program that played the music people wanted to hear combined with his groovy
upbeat personality. You will need an outside antenna to get clear reception on your radio.


Feel free to surf to my weblog :: khapk.com

Anonymous said...

If, at the end of this time period, the score is tied, there
are two options the officials can take. Caution:
when a hole is made in a can, there may be metallic edges that
can cut one's mouth. In addition, you can save the effort of coding the store functionality, virtual goods dependencies, billing interfaces and rewards.

Look into my blog post; Read A great deal more

Anonymous said...

What is the most important portion is the sincere words that you put together in the poems that will catch the attention of the one you loved as this is what you truly want from the romantic poems that you have created for him.
Love poems intensify the feeling of love in the minds of lovers.
There are many famous author books published on poems.


my webpage - http://www.gedichtzurgeburt.de/wp-admin/options-writing.php

Anonymous said...

In the four tournaments since his first of the season, he.

A bowler who can consistently pick up his spares can easily hold
a 180 average without getting any strikes. You can also customize the car
including retractable hanggliders.

Feel free to visit my page: http://www.dn.npu.edu.ua/user/view.php?id=53625&course=1

Anonymous said...

Upon examining some etymological dictionaries, one can conclude that
games are a creative expression of the human spirit through the creation of
an activity that has an entertaining, instructive
and competing element. This way you are not disappointed when you get residence, and you
won't have to make a excursion back to the shop. Well, you can have that same chess engine on your Android mobile phone, courtesy of Droid - Fish.

My web blog ... kostenlos spielen

Anonymous said...

The pc 2007 elite TV software is therefore legitimate
software with over 3000 TV channels. I think
what corporate America has forgotten is that the airwaves are public.
Having had my nearby store shut down recently I looked around for another place where I could get
my gear from but unfortunately could not find any good
outlets even remotely close to my home so started
looking online.

Here is my homepage; Suggested Website

Anonymous said...

Once the game is 80% complete you will need to work on the sound.
t want to forget to buy your all star game tickets at Angels Stadium from
an independent ticket broker that cares more about customer satisfaction than
the bottom line. As ever we strive to help our customers make informed decisions and understand where their r4
cards are coming from.

Here is my website: www.northpride.altervista.org

Anonymous said...

The fishfinder approximates where the fish are by measuring the amount of time between when the beam was sent out
and when it registered the hit. One of the benefits of fishing
is that it is not physically demanding. If the fish are not hitting on your
main crappie jigs you may need to switch to live bait or a combination of live and artificial baits.


Feel free to surf to my webpage: statkiewicz.com

Anonymous said...

The Squeezbox Boom radio from Logitech is not just an Internet radio.
"It's hard to believe, " says Randy Gilbert, host of
“The Inside Success Secrets Radio Show"-an Internet radio broadcast which has been “airing" for several years.
Raima has options to limit individual file sizes
in the preferences dialog.

my weblog; internetradio aussetzer

Anonymous said...

Believing that you are actually starving, it releases chemicals that actually make it harder
to lose weight in an effort to conserve energy.
Vitamin B3 or also called as Niacin is important in weight loss because it
is responsible for the regulation of thyroid hormones and also in sugar levels in the body.
Many people don't have the time to weight themselves every day, but checking the scale on a regular basis can definitely help when you're working to lose weight and keep it off.


my web-site; http://Www.marknadsplatsen.se/

Anonymous said...

So how do you select the finest shop from all the retailers that offer this camera.
This 12 megapixel camera is capable of capturing 3D photos too.

This lets you manage exactly how wide the camera shutter opens and the remaining settings are
governed automatically to provide you with an excellent
picture.

My web-site ... http://jfpc.kr/zbxe/index.php?document_srl=43203&mid=freeboard

Anonymous said...

For many regions, the entire rpm distributed free of charge STB The costs have been overwhelmed, and
then implementation of the Reconstruction of two-way network, the funding is clearly beyond its capability.
Listening to Internet radio is a breeze for anyone who's familiar with the World Wide Web. Turn on iheartradio and then look at a different app, your station will keep playing and you can control everything from the "running apps" menu (double-click the home button).

my web-site; simply click the next website

Anonymous said...

I have been in touch with many musicians, artists that I would have never heard
before. In my case I listen to all music that is submitted to me before I include it
on my playlist. Raima has options to limit individual file sizes
in the preferences dialog.

Also visit my site - Internet Radio

Anonymous said...

Funny Or Die separates itself from other funny
video clip hosting sites by the way it lets people rank the videos, get enough funny votes and the video will
be immortalized get enough die votes and the video will be sent into the
"crypt". Listening to Internet radio is a breeze for anyone who's familiar with the World Wide Web. Many think that having thoughts of supposed happiness that will never come is futile and that they are only giving false hopes to those who need them the most.

Also visit my web blog ... www.online-radioportal.de

Anonymous said...

Believing that you are actually starving, it releases chemicals that actually make it harder
to lose weight in an effort to conserve energy. Withdrawal from levothyroxine can be done but it takes
6 weeks of withdrawal for the remaining thyroid tissue to be completely starved.
Now, the average healthy amount people are supposed to lose is 2 pounds per week.


My web site: http://www.clevelandwebstandards.org/member/919/

Anonymous said...

Break your 3 normal main meals into 5 smaller portion
sizes - morning, snack, lunch, snack, dinner. Withdrawal
from levothyroxine can be done but it takes 6 weeks of
withdrawal for the remaining thyroid tissue to be completely starved.

Do not be tempted to lose weight as quickly as you can, because a crash diet will have you eating less than a
thousand calories a day slowing down your metabolism.


Review my web-site ... http://speckdesign.com/s=0825a3dc0aca10d84677d0177d7f097628359228/Member/2388

Anonymous said...

It does appear, however, that hypnosis can help
a person achieve his or her weight loss goals. Withdrawal from levothyroxine can be done but it
takes 6 weeks of withdrawal for the remaining thyroid tissue to be completely starved.
The institution has persistently offered ideal programs and services
for those struggling to achieve certain levels of body
weight.

Check out my site; Full Statement

Anonymous said...

So how do you select the finest shop from all the retailers that offer this camera.
If, you are from one of those who think the higher megapixel
camera is best then you are surely mistaken. Some cameras are simple point and shoot while others have many different modes for taking pictures.


Feel free to surf to my homepage; Sony Digital Camera Accessories Philippines

Anonymous said...

You don't have to hit the gym for two and three hours each day to lose weight, but it does help to squeeze in 30 minutes of physical activity each day. Avocados- Although not my favorite, are high in fats, the good ones. Who does not need that little bit of elevation when trying to diet.

My web page - www.donglpho.com

Anonymous said...

Body is solid and is made up of magnesium alloy which
makes this camera durable to last longer. This 12 megapixel
camera is capable of capturing 3D photos too. The
Difference Between Digital and Optical Zooms Many digital cameras feature
both digital and optical zoom.

My webpage - Related Web-site

Anonymous said...

For any kind of luxury item of consumption, MAD (Money, Authority and Desire) is required.

Hardware mechanisms used in the manufacturing of a Wi - Fi internet
radio system is less complicated and the point of ergonomics is
kept in mind by the manufactures. You will need an outside
antenna to get clear reception on your radio.


My page: Radio nowhere springsteen

Anonymous said...

Major follows some sports, primarily during the playoffs.
This means to sell your mods would be considered the same
as pirating the game itself. This classic game integrates all-out entertainment with vocabulary enhancement in one
amazing game.

My webpage ... mouse click the following webpage

Anonymous said...

Break your 3 normal main meals into 5 smaller portion sizes - morning, snack,
lunch, snack, dinner. In fact, I always suggest to those overweight vegetarians to keep to a max of 4 pounds a week so you
won't suffer loose skin post weight loss. Now, the average healthy amount people are supposed to lose is 2 pounds per week.

Also visit my weblog ... Highly recommended Online site

Anonymous said...

This is more important than ever in a world where there are dozens of different audio formats.
So your personal, non-commercial, watercraft is exempt from a licensing requirement.

Perfect for long trips and for up to date information on
road conditions ahead.

Also visit my web page: radio Vision 20000 haiti

Anonymous said...

Essentially the most commonly used supplies are
psyllium husks, flax seeds, probiotics, apple juice, citrus juice, fiber
powder, bentonite clay, fennel, garlic bulb, turkey rhubarb,
curacao, cape aloe leaf, cascara sagrada, barberry
root bark, ginger rhizome and cayenne pepper. Add chicken stock (liter) and bring to boil, add salt
to taste, chicken seasoning, ground peppercorn, vetsin, cabbage and noodles.
You will need to obtain the following ingredients to make one gallon of liquid goat's
milk soap:.

my website; recipes com swiss chard recipes (www.stanfest.com)

Post a Comment